por Lauren Dubinsky
, Senior Reporter | August 10, 2020
From the August 2020 issue of HealthCare Business News magazine
At the 2019 Radiological Society of North America (RSNA) annual meeting, Varex introduced liquid metal bearing technology to its X-ray tube portfolio including its FP-1596-LMB tube for cardiovascular applications and its G-507X-LMB for CT applications. For the first time, Varex offers a lease option on these new tubes.
Also at the 2019 RSNA meeting, Dunlee announced plans to launch a liquid metal bearing tube in the replacement space.
Midwest Hand Surgery Auction Closing 5/26 at 8PM. Hologic Fluoroscan Insight-FD Mini C-Arm, Nuvo Dual-Lamp Surgical Lighting System W/Control Panel, Ritter M11 Ultraclave Automatic Sterilizer & More! 2 Day Women's Treatment Center Auction Coming Soon!
“Currently, all dealers and customers have no choice but to buy from the OEM, because today there are no alternatives for liquid bearing technology in the market,” said Alexander Eitel, head of marketing and business development at Dunlee. “By bringing the product to the market, we are giving them a choice to manage their cost and it means they don’t have to be as dependent on the OEM.”
The case for conventional tubes
Despite its revolutionary cooling benefits, liquid metal bearing technology does come with a few drawbacks — cost being the main one.
Replacing one of these tubes can cost between a third or half of the cost of the original CT scanner, according to Jerald Olsen, vice president of sales and business development at Richardson Healthcare. Because of that, a service contract with the OEM is needed to mitigate that risk.
In addition, liquid metal bearing technology may limit the gantry rotation speed. As gantry speed is increased, it requires a more precise liquid metal bearing to handle the increased G loads, according to Olsen.
“A liquid metal bearing requires a special drive motor for the anode and these need to be incorporated into the design of the CT scanner,” he added. The torque required to start the bearing in rotation is high, and up-to-speed time is not as fast as a conventional ball bearing.”
These tubes tend to last longer than conventional ball bearing tubes, but in general, CT tube life varies greatly. A tube in similar scanners can last anywhere from two months to two years, according to Launders.
“One of the issues I see is that the manufacturers own the data on the longevity of the tubes,” he said. “Unless you have your own biomeds that service your CT scanners and you’re a large hospital, you probably have very little idea of the longevity of the CT tube because you won’t have enough CT scanners at the same site to track that data.”